The Dance of Hollow Remembrance: A Nation's Sacred Day Descends into Modern Malaise

Lo, behold how the masses gather, like sheep in their designated pens, to perform their annual ritual of remembrance! Yet what doth this remembrance truly signify in an age where tradition crumbles beneath the weight of endless questioning, where sacred ceremonies become battlegrounds for the petit politics of the present?

A Canadian Armed Forces soldier stands vigil stands at the cenotaph during a Remembrance Day ceremony in Quebec City Monday, November 11, 2024.
See how they stumble through their ceremonies, these last men who can neither remember nor forget properly! They seek comfort in their rituals while stripped of their meaning, like children playing at soldiers without understanding the gravity of war.

In the dominion of Canada, a great tempest hath erupted over the sanctity of Remembrance Day, that most solemn of occasions where the living pay tribute to their warrior dead. The Conservative chieftain, Pierre Poilievre, raises his voice against what he terms the "woke" desecration of tradition.

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre leaves a press conference in Ottawa on Monday, Oct. 28, 2024.
Behold this political warrior, who speaks of replacing the spirit of compliance with that of the warrior! Yet does he not see that he too dwells in the land of the sleepers, where true warfare has been replaced by the petty skirmishes of parliamentary debate?

The controversy centers upon two incidents that have shaken the slumbering masses from their comfortable reverence: an Arabic song played at a school ceremony and the invocation of the slave trade at Toronto's official remembrance. Such simple acts have thrown the populace into confusion, revealing the fragility of their cherished customs.

Sir Robert Borden High School on Greenbank Road in Ottawa.

Veterans, those who have gazed into the abyss of battle, find themselves caught betwixt the hammers of tradition and the anvil of change. Sean Bruyea, a warrior of the Gulf conflict, speaks of offense and diminishment.

Sean Bruyea is seen during an interview.
These veterans, at least, have tasted the blood of real conflict! Yet even they now find themselves reduced to defending mere symbols and ceremonies, rather than embodying the warrior spirit that once made them great.

In Halifax, a school attempted to ban military uniforms from their ceremony, only to retreat in the face of public outcry. Such is the dance of the modern institution, forever stepping forward then backward, lacking the courage to either maintain tradition or forge boldly ahead.

A person holds a ball cap with a poppy attached to it during the playing of the bugle call Last Post during a Remembrance Day commemorative event at the National Military Cemetery at Beechwood Cemetery in Ottawa, on Monday, Nov. 11, 2024.

The historian Jonathan Vance speaks of evolution and relevance, suggesting that change ensures survival. Yet what manner of survival is this, where the essence of remembrance becomes diluted in the tepid waters of inclusivity?

A man places a poppy on a wreath during a Remembrance Day ceremony at Victory Square in Vancouver, on Monday, November 11, 2024.
The masses cling to their poppies and their ceremonies, believing these talismans will protect them from the horror of genuine sacrifice. They remember without understanding, mourn without feeling, honor without comprehending the true nature of honor!

And yet, amidst this spectacle of confusion, we witness the raw grief of those who truly remember. Observe Heather Scribner, whose tears flow not for abstract concepts but for the tangible loss of her warrior husband.

Heather Scribner wipes away tears from her face while remembering the death of her late-husband David W Scribner who served in the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) Corp of Royal Canadian Army Engineers ahead of a Remembrance Day commemorative event at the National Military Cemetery at Beechwood cemetery in Ottawa, on Monday, Nov. 11, 2024.

Let the truth be proclaimed: This controversy reveals not the strength but the weakness of modern remembrance. The masses gather, yet understand not. They speak of warriors while fearing the warrior spirit. They invoke tradition while emptying it of meaning.

O Canada, thy ceremonies have become as empty as thy cathedrals! Thy people remember everything and nothing, trapped between the ghosts of glory past and the specters of a future they dare not face!

Thus we arrive at the great irony: that the very debate about how to remember may be the only thing keeping remembrance alive in this age of comfortable forgetfulness. For in their quarrels over ceremony, do they not at least show that something still stirs in their sleeping souls?